Calder Willingham

Calder Willingham

lder Baynard Willingham, Jr. (December 23, 1922 - February 19, 1995) was an American novelist and screenwriter.

Before the age of thirty, after just three novels and a collection of short stories, The New Yorker was already describing Willingham as having “fathered modern black comedy,” his signature a dry, straight-faced humor, made funnier by its concealed comic intent. His work matured over six more novels, including Eternal Fire (1963), which Newsweek said “deserves a place among the dozen or so novels that must be mentioned if one is to speak of greatness in American fiction.” He had a significant career in cinema, too, as a frequent collaborator of Stanley Kubrick as well writing The Graduate (1967) and other notable films.

After dropping out of The Citadel, then working for the Office of War Information in Washington, Willingham moved to New York where he wrote for ten years, setting three novels there. During the late ‘40s and early ‘50s, Willingham was considered at the forefront of the gritty, realistic new breed of Post-War novelists, Norman Mailer, James Jones, Truman Capote, Gore Vidal and others, many of whom also made up the Greenwich Village literary scene at the time.

Willingham’s career began in controversy with End as a Man (1947), a withering indictment of the macho culture of military academies, introducing his first iconic character, sadistic Jocko de Paris. The story included graphic hazing, sex and suggested homosexuality, which in a climate celebrating military victory, led the New York Society for the Suppression of Vice to file obscenity charges against its publisher, Vanguard Press. The charges were ultimately dropped, but not before a trial which made the book a cause celebre, famous writers rallying to its defense. Reviews singled out its savage humor and realistic dialogue.

Willingham turned the book into a play at New York’s Actor's Studio, where it was an off-Broadway success featuring a young James Dean and also introduced actor, George Peppard. One of Hollywood’s top producers, Sam Spiegel, subsequently commissioned Willingham to adapt the novel to film, his first, re-titled The Strange One (1957) for Columbia Pictures, who advertised it as “the first picture filmed entirely by a cast and technicians from The Actors’s Studio.” Ben Gazarra’s debut got raves and launched his career.

Willingham followed it up with the first in a semi-autobiographical trilogy of novels about an aspiring writer, Dick Davenport. Geraldine Bradshaw (1950) was set in a Chicago hotel during the War where Dick works as a bell-boy (as Willingham had), lusting after a new elevator girl. Its sexual explicitness divided critics who felt its subject beneath his gifts but it sold well and has maintained a cultish following among writers; for example, William Styron reported visiting William Faulkner and noticing it prominently placed on his desk, and it appears on various published lists of “lost classics.” The original version was 415 pages but a 1964 edition, considerably shorter, is definitive and included a foreword from Willingham explaining how the pressure of End As A Man’s success led him to the grandiose idea of filling out the follow-up book with obscure references to the next two in the trilogy. “Success is always dangerous, and early success is deadly," he said in a 1953 interview. “What I went through writing my second book shouldn't happen to a dog."

Next came a second Dick Davenport novel, Reach to the Stars (1951), Dick as a bell-boy in Los Angeles (which Willingham had also been), making observations and sexual hay on the fringe of the upscale Hollywood scene. In 1951, Willingham also published his lone book of short stories, Gates of Hell (1951), mostly comic, the book was revered in literary circles. In 1970, Tom Wolfe called the book "the most undeservedly neglected book since World War II" referring to Willingham as "the great comic genius of American fiction."

Natural Child (1952), Willingham’s first New York novel, was a portrait of two young men and two young women living the bohemian lifestyle of the time. The sophisticated plotting combined with Willingham’s ear for realistic dialogue in one of the lesser-known gems in his collection. To Eat a Peach (1955) chronicled life and lust among adults running a summer camp. Confusion about just how to place writing considered both literary and prurient resulted in the release of two different paperback versions, one with the original title and another with racy cover art re-titled The Girl in the Dogwood Cabin. The seeming ease with which it was written bolstered rumors the novel had been written start-to-finish in three weeks, which turned out to be true.

Busy with film work, it was eight years before Willingham’s next novel, his most ambitious, Eternal Fire (1963), an epic set in Glenville, Georgia, a fictional stand-in for his home town of Rome. It chronicles the proposed marriage of a young heir to a virtuous schoolteacher, plagued by inexplicable suicidal thoughts. It got the best reviews of Willingham’s career, sold well, and firmly established him as one of the major authors of his day. Shelby Foote said the novel convinced him that Willingham was about “the only living American writer qualified to hold Dostoevsky’s coat in a street fight.”

Busy in Hollywood, it was six years until the next novel, another epic, Providence Island (1969), in which a male television executive is shipwrecked with a repressed, married woman and a plain, shy, androgynous one. The book was not as well reviewed as its predecessor but became a best-seller in paperback. Twentieth Century Fox paid a near-record amount to buy the rights for husband and wife Paul Newman and Joanne Woodward but never made the movie.

The novels came slower as Willingham became a more prolific screenwriter. After the film version of End As A Man, producer Spiegel asked Willingham to write The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957) for director David Lean. While reportedly writing over 90% of the script, Willingham walked off in a quarrel with Spiegel despite Spiegel’s threat to take Willingham’s name off the credits, a promise Spiegel kept, and they never worked together again. The film swept the 30th Academy Awards winning seven Oscars including Best Picture and Best Screenplay, which was credited to Pierre Boulle, author of the book on which it’s based, who did no work on the film. Ironically, forty years later, the Writers Guild gave screenwriting credit to Carl Foreman and Michael Wilson who’d been blacklisted during the McCarthy era and who’d each also worked on the script subsequent to Willingham’s departure.

Paths of Glory (1957) was Willingham’s first collaboration with Stanley Kubrick. Willingham’s dry, ironic humor meshed well with Kubrick’s bravura directorial style. The film, starring Kirk Douglas, remains one of the classic anti-war films ever made. It was produced independently and ignored by the Academy but made a splash with Hollywood’s brainier crowd. Willingham and Kubrick were immediately hired to write and direct another, a film based on Stefan Zweig’s novel, The Burning Secret, but it was never produced. Willingham also continued working with Kirk Douglas, writing The Vikings (1958), a box-office hit starring Douglas, Tony Curtis and Janet Leigh. Kubrick then replaced Anthony Mann as director during filming of Spartacus (1960), which Douglas was also producing, and Willingham came on to rewrite the screenplay and battle sequences.

Though Willingham dropped out of the literary scene when he left New York in 1953, he maintained his friendship with Vladimir Nabokov. Broke and isolated, Nabokov was teaching at Cornell University and considering moving from America. Willingham encouraged him to try to sell his books to Hollywood and passed along a copy of Lolita to Kubrick, who agreed to buy it. Willingham arranged the deal and wrote the first drafts, before giving way to Nabokov, who’d never written a screenplay but contributed significantly and also profited financially. The film, starring Peter Sellers, James Mason, Shelly Winters and Sue Lyon is one of Kubrick’s best, and the screenplay, credited to Nakobov but really an amalgam of Willingham, Nakobov and Kubrick’s work, was nominated for an Academy Award. Willingham’s fifth and final collaboration with Kubrick was a western, One-Eyed Jacks (1961), to star Marlon Brando. The three collaborated on the story for a year before Kubrick left and Brando directed himself in the film.

Willingham’s next assignment was adapting Charles Webb’s novel, The Graduate for director Mike Nichols. The script was revised by Buck Henry, who also received screenplay credit. The film was nominated for 7 Academy Awards including Best Picture and Best Screenplay. Willingham’s collaboration with actor Dustin Hoffman continued with an adaptation of Thomas Berger’s Little Big Man, for which Willingham was nominated for Writer’s Guild Award. They attempted a third collaboration, an adaptation of Malcolm Braly’s prison memoir On The Yard, but it was never made. During this period, Willingham also wrote an extended treatment for the film, Patton (1970) and a screenplay for Robert Altman’s Thieves Like Us (1974).

But Willingham always considered film work secondary to his books. His penultimate novel, Rambling Rose (1972), was an autobiographical story about his childhood in Georgia featuring comic characterizations of his parents and siblings. The one fictional character is Rose, an eroticized housekeeper who comes to stay with the family as Buddy, age twelve, is just beginning to become curious about sex.

His last novel, The Big Nickel (1975), completed the Dick Davenport trilogy conceived twenty-five years earlier in the wake of first success.

Soon after, Willingham went through a cataclysm: his New Hampshire house burned down, destroying all of his personal papers. He stopped working and regained his health, reading and reflecting during a decade of philosophical and spiritual reevaluation. He re-emerged in 1989 to do movie work again, his first assignment, adapting one of his own novels directly to the screen.

Rambling Rose (1991) starred Robert Duvall, Diane Ladd and Laura Dern as Rose, and although only a modest success, Ladd and Dern were the first mother-daughter team to be nominated together for Academy Awards for their work in the film. Willingham also began a screenplay for Steven Spielberg in 1994 entitled Julie’s Valley about a pioneer family attacked by Native Americans on the Oregon Trail; however, after delivering the draft, he was diagnosed with lung cancer and died February 19, 1995, and the film was never made.

Willingham’s work is now generally out of print. In a biography written for the Literary Guild, author Herman Wouk blamed a twist of fate, a newspaper strike coinciding with publication of Eternal Fire, limiting its readership. Publisher Donald I. Fine echoed this notion in his re-issue of the book in 1986, and perhaps this is a partial explanation why Eternal Fire, arguably deserving of recognition by the literary awards which would have secured him a brighter place in the post-War pantheon, was overlooked. At the same time, as early as 1969, an article entitled “Calder Willingham: The Forgotten Novelist,” appeared in a literary quarterly and most references to him even today refer to him as one of the under-appreciated talents of his generation.