All-Americans
Since the first All-American team was selected by Casper Whitney in 1889, more than 100 Yale football players have been selected as first-team All-Americans. Consensus All-Americans are noted below with bold typeface.
- 1889: Amos Alonzo Stagg (end), Charles O. Gill (tackle), Pudge Heffelfinger (guard)
- 1890: William Rhodes (tackle), Pudge Heffelfinger, Lee McClung (halfback)
- 1891: Frank Hinkey (end), Josh Hartwell (end), Wallace Winter (tackle), Pudge Heffelfinger (guard), Lee McClung (halfback)
- 1892: Frank Hinkey (end), Alexander Hamilton Wallis (tackle), Vance McCormick (halfback)
- 1893: Frank Hinkey (end), Bill Hickock (guard), Frank Butterworth (halfback)
- 1894: Frank Hinkey (end), Anson Beard (tackle), Bill Hickock (guard), Phillip Stillman (center), George Adee (quarterback), Frank Butterworth (fullback)
- 1895: Fred Murphy (tackle), Sam Thorne (halfback)
- 1896: Lyman Bass (end), Fred Murphy (tackle), Burr Chamberlain (center), Clarence Fincke (quarterback)
- 1897: John Hall (end), Burr Chamberlain (tackle), Rodgers (tackle), Gordon Brown (guard), Charles Chadwick (guard), George Cadwalader (center), Charles de Saulles (quarterback)
- 1898: Burr Chamberlain (guard), Gordon Brown (guard), Malcolm McBride (halfback)
- 1899: George Stillman (tackle), Gordon Brown (guard), Albert Sharpe (halfback), Malcolm McBride (fullback)
- 1900: Sherman Coy (end), George Stillman (tackle), James Bloomer (tackle), Gordon Brown (guard), Herman Olcott (center), George Chadwick (halfback), William Finck (halfback), Albert Sharpe (halfback), Perry Hale (fullback)
- 1901: James Hogan (tackle), Herman Olcott (guard), Henry Holt (center)
- 1902: Tom Shevlin (end), Ralph Kinney (tackle), James Hogan (tackle), Edward Glass (guard), Henry Holt (center), Foster Rockwell (quarterback), George Chadwick (halfback), Harold Metcalf (halfback), Morgan Bowman (fullback)
- 1903: Charles Rafferty (end), Tom Shevlin (end), James Hogan (tackle), James Bloomer (guard), Foster Rockwell (quarterback), Harold Metcalf (halfback), Ledyard Mitchell (fullback)
- 1904: Tom Shevlin (end), Neal (end), James Hogan (tackle), James Bloomer (tackle), Ralph Kinney (guard), Roswell Tripp (guard), Clint Roraback (center), Foster Rockwell (quarterback), Lydig Hoyt (halfback)
- 1905: Tom Shevlin (end), Roswell Tripp (guard), Guy Hutchinson (quarterback), Howard Roome (halfback)
- 1906: Robert Forbes (end), Lucius Horatio Biglow (tackle), Arthur Brides (guard), Clarence Hockenberger (center), Tad Jones (quarterback), Hugh Knox (halfback), Paul Veeder (fullback), Samuel F.B. Morse (fullback)
- 1907: Clarence Alcott (end), Lucius Horatio Biglow (tackle), Tad Jones (quarterback), Ted Coy (fullback)
- 1908: William Goebel (guard), Hamlin Andrus (guard), Ted Coy (fullback)
- 1909: John Kilpatrick (end), Henry Hobbs (tackle), Hamlin Andrus (guard), Carroll Cooney (center), Stephen Philbin (halfback), Ted Coy (fullback)
- 1910: John Kilpatrick (end), Jim Scully (tackle), Fred J. Daly (halfback)
- 1911: Douglas Bomeisler (end), Jim Scully (tackle), Pomeroy Francis (guard), Hank Ketcham (center), Art Howe (quarterback), Jesse Philbin (fullback)
- 1912: Douglas Bomeisler (end), Carroll T. Cooney (guard), Hank Ketcham (center)
- 1913: Ben Avery (end), Bud Talbott (tackle), John Pendleton (guard), Hank Ketcham (guard), William Marting (center)
- 1914: Red Brann (end), Bud Talbott (tackle), Harry LeGore (fullback)
- 1915: Clinton Black (guard)
- 1916: Charles Comerford (end), George Moseley (end), Clinton Black (guard), Lawrence Fox (guard)
- 1920: Tim Callahan (guard), John Acosta (guard)
- 1921: Malcolm Aldrich (halfback)
- 1922: Harry Cross (guard), Phillip Cruikshank (guard)
- 1923: Century Milstead (tackle), Bill Mallory (fullback)
- 1924: Dick Luman (end), Johnny H. Joss (tackle), Winslow Lovejoy (center), Ducky Pond (halfback)
- 1925: Johnny H. Joss (tackle), Herbert Sturhahn (guard)
- 1926: Herbert Sturhahn (guard)
- 1927: Dwight Fishwick (end), Sidney Quarrier (tackle), Bill Webster (guard), John Charlesworth (center), Bruce Caldwell (halfback)
- 1929: Wade Greene (guard), Albie Booth (quarterback)
- 1930: Frederick Linehan (guard)
- 1932: Robert Lassiter (halfback)
- 1936: Larry Kelley (end), Clint Frank (quarterback)
- 1937: Clint Frank (quarterback)
- 1942: Spencer Moseley (center)
- 1944: Paul Walker (end)
- 1945: Paul Walker (end)
- 1960: Ben Balme (guard)
- 1970: Tom Neville (tackle)
- 1972: Dick Jauron (running back)
- 1977: John Pagliaro (running back)
- 1981: Rich Diana (running back)
Read more about this topic: Yale Bulldogs Football