World Wide Web Consortium - Recommendations and Certifications

Recommendations and Certifications

In accord with the W3C Process Document, a Recommendation progresses through four maturity levels:

1. Working Draft
2. Candidate Recommendation'
3. Proposed Recommendation'
4. W3C Recommendation (REC).

Both Candidate and Proposed Recommendations may enter "Last Call" to signal that any further feedback must be provided expeditiously. In addition, "Editor's Drafts" may be published to show work in progress.

A Recommendation may be updated by separately published Errata until enough substantial edits accumulate, at which time a new edition of the Recommendation may be produced (e.g., XML is now in its fifth edition). W3C also publishes various kinds of informative Notes which are not intended to be treated as standards.

W3C leaves it up to manufacturers to follow the Recommendations. Many of its standards define levels of conformance, which the developers must follow if they wish to label their product W3C-compliant. Like any standards of other organizations, W3C recommendations are sometimes implemented partially. The Recommendations are under a royalty-free patent license, allowing anyone to implement them.

Unlike the ISOC and other international standards bodies, the W3C does not have a certification program. A certification program is a process which has benefits and drawbacks; the W3C has decided, for now, that it is not suitable to start such a program owing to the risk of creating more drawbacks for the community than benefits.