Filmography
| Year | Film | Role | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1914 | Her Own Money | uncredited | |
| 1918 | All Woman | uncredited | |
| 1919 | Lombardi, Ltd. | uncredited | |
| 1921 | First Love | Donald Halliday | |
| Cheated Hearts | Tom Gordon | ||
| The Love Charm | Thomas Morgan | ||
| Sheltered Daughters | Pep Mullins | ||
| 1922 | If I Were Queen | Vladimir | |
| A Girl's Desire | Jones/Lord Dysart | ||
| The Ninety and Nine | Tom Silverton/Phil Bradbury | ||
| The Girl in His Room | Kirk Waring | ||
| Her Own Money | Lew Alden | ||
| 1923 | St. Elmo | Murray Hammond | |
| Blow Your Own Horn | Jack Dunbar | ||
| In Search of a Thrill | Adrian Torrens | ||
| Those Who Dance | Bob Kane | ||
| 1924 | Christine of the Hungry Heart | Stuart Knight | |
| The Female | Col. Valentia | ||
| His Forgotten Wife | Donald Allen/John Rolfe | ||
| Alimony | Jimmy Mason | ||
| The Garden of Weeds | Douglas Crawford | ||
| 1925 | The Best People | Henry Morgan | |
| A Son of His Father | Big Boy Morgan | ||
| Rugged Water | Calvin Horner | ||
| Welcome Home | Fred Prouty | ||
| The Awful Truth | Norman Satterlee | ||
| The Air Mail | Russ Kane | ||
| The Golden Bed | Bunny O'Neill | ||
| Mismates | Ted Carroll | ||
| 1926 | Aloma of the South Seas | Nuitane | |
| The Runaway | Wade Murrell | ||
| Mannequin | John Herrick | ||
| The Great Gatsby | Jay Gatsby | now a lost film | |
| Miss Brewster's Millions | Thomas B. Hancock Jr | ||
| 1927 | The Coward | Clinton Philbrook | |
| Singed | Royce Wingate | ||
| Drums of the Desert | John Curry | ||
| The Telephone Girl | Matthew Standish | ||
| Craig's Wife | Walter Craig | ||
| 1928 | Danger Street | Rolly Sigsby | |
| Ramona | Alessandro | ||
| Three Sinners | James Harris | ||
| The Tragedy of Youth | Frank Gordon | ||
| West of Zanzibar | Doc | directed by Tod Browning | |
| A Woman's Way | Tony | ||
| In Old Arizona | The Cisco Kid | Academy Award for Best Actor | |
| 1929 | Romance of the Rio Grande | Pablo Wharton Cameron | |
| Behind That Curtain | Col. John Beetham | ||
| The Far Call | |||
| Thru Different Eyes | Jack Winfield | ||
| Linda | Dr. Paul Randall | ||
| 1930 | Renegades | Deucalion | |
| Such Men Are Dangerous | Ludwig Kranz | ||
| The Arizona Kid | The Cisco Kid | ||
| The Squaw Man | James 'Jim' Wingate, aka Jim Carston | ||
| 1931 | Their Mad Moment | Esteban Cristera | |
| Doctors' Wives | Dr. Judson Penning | ||
| The Stolen Jools | The Cisco Kid | ||
| Daddy Long Legs | Jervis Pendleton | ||
| The Cisco Kid | The Cisco Kid | ||
| Surrender | Sgt. Dumaine | ||
| 1932 | Six Hours to Live | Capt. Paul Onslow | |
| Man About Town | Stephen Morrow | ||
| Amateur Daddy | Jim Gladden | ||
| 1933 | Dangerously Yours | Andrew Burke | |
| 42nd Street | Julian Marsh | ||
| I Loved You Wednesday | Philip Fletcher | ||
| Paddy the Next Best Thing | Lawrence Blake | ||
| Penthouse | Jackson 'Jack' Durant | ||
| 1934 | Hell in the Heavens | Lt. Steve Warner | |
| As Husbands Go | Charles Lingard | ||
| Grand Canary | Dr. Harvey Leith | ||
| Stand Up and Cheer! | Lawrence Cromwell | ||
| Such Women Are Dangerous | Michael Shawn | ||
| Broadway Bill | Dan Brooks | ||
| 1935 | Under the Pampas Moon | Cesar Campo | |
| One More Spring | Jaret Otkar | ||
| La Fiesta de Santa Barbara | Short film | ||
| 1936 | White Hunter | Capt. Clark Rutledge | |
| To Mary – with Love | Jack Wallace | ||
| The Road to Glory | Captain Paul La Roche | ||
| The Prisoner of Shark Island | Dr. Samuel Mudd | ||
| King of Burlesque | Kerry Bolton | ||
| The Robin Hood of El Dorado | Joaquin Murrieta | ||
| 1937 | Wife, Doctor and Nurse | Dr. Judd Lewis | |
| Vogues of 1938 | George Curson | ||
| Slave Ship | Jim Lovett | ||
| 1938 | I'll Give a Million | Tony Newlander | |
| Kidnapped | Alan Breck | ||
| 1939 | Barricade | Hank Topping | |
| Wife, Husband and Friend | Leonard Borland aka Logan Bennett | ||
| Return of the Cisco Kid | The Cisco Kid | ||
| 1940 | Earthbound | Nick Desborough | |
| 1941 | Adam Had Four Sons | Adam Stoddard | |
| 1943 | Crime Doctor | Dr. Robert Ordway, formerly Phil Morgan | first of 10 films in the Crime Doctor B-film series |
| Crime Doctor's Strangest Case | Dr. Robert Ordway | ||
| 1944 | Shadows in the Night | Dr. Robert Ordway | |
| Lady in the Dark | Kendall Nesbitt | ||
| 1945 | Crime Doctor's Warning | Dr. Robert Ordway | |
| The Crime Doctor's Courage | Dr. Robert Ordway | ||
| 1946 | Crime Doctor's Man Hunt | Dr. Robert Ordway | |
| Just Before Dawn | Dr. Robert Ordway | ||
| 1947 | Crime Doctor's Gamble | Dr. Robert Ordway | |
| The Millerson Case | Dr. Robert Ordway | ||
| 1948 | The Gentleman from Nowhere | Earl Donovan/Robert Ashton | |
| 1949 | The Crime Doctor's Diary | Dr. Robert Ordway | last of the Crime Doctor series |
| The Devil's Henchman | Jess Arno | ||
| Prison Warden | Warden Victor Burnell | ||
| 1950 | State Penitentiary | Rodger Manners | |
| 1952 | O. Henry's Full House | clip of Baxter from The Cisco Kid |
Read more about this topic: Warner Baxter