Vickrey Auction - Proof of Dominance of Truthful Bidding

Proof of Dominance of Truthful Bidding

The dominant strategy in a Vickrey auction with a single, indivisible item is for each bidder to bid their true value of the item.

Let be bidder i's value for the item. Let be bidder i's bid for the item.

The payoff for bidder i is \begin{cases} v_i-\max_{j\neq i} b_j & \text{if } b_i > \max_{j\neq i} b_j \\ 0 & \text{otherwise} \end{cases}

The strategy of overbidding is dominated by bidding truthfully. Assume that bidder i bids .

If then the bidder would win the item with a truthful bid as well as an overbid. The bid's amount does not change the payoff so the two strategies have equal payoffs in this case.

If then the bidder would lose the item either way so the strategies have equal payoffs in this case.

If then only the strategy of overbidding would win the auction. The payoff would be negative for the strategy of overbidding because they paid more than their value of the item, while the payoff for a truthful bid would be zero. Thus the strategy of bidding higher than one's true valuation is dominated by the strategy of truthfully bidding.

The strategy of underbidding is dominated by bidding truthfully. Assume that bidder i bids .

If then the bidder would lose the item with a truthful bid as well as an underbid, so the strategies have equal payoffs for this case.

If then the bidder would win the item either way so the strategies have equal payoffs in this case.

If then only the strategy of truthfully bidding would win the auction. The payoff for the truthful strategy would be positive as they paid less than their value of the item, while the payoff for an underbid bid would be zero. Thus the strategy of underbidding is dominated by the strategy of truthfully bidding.

Truthful bidding dominates the other possible strategies (underbidding and overbidding) so it is an optimal strategy.

Read more about this topic:  Vickrey Auction

Famous quotes containing the words proof of, proof, dominance, truthful and/or bidding:

    “Sculpture and painting are very justly called liberal arts; a lively and strong imagination, together with a just observation, being absolutely necessary to excel in either; which, in my opinion, is by no means the case of music, though called a liberal art, and now in Italy placed even above the other two—a proof of the decline of that country.”
    —Philip Dormer Stanhope, 4th Earl Chesterfield (1694–1773)

    “Sculpture and painting are very justly called liberal arts; a lively and strong imagination, together with a just observation, being absolutely necessary to excel in either; which, in my opinion, is by no means the case of music, though called a liberal art, and now in Italy placed even above the other two—a proof of the decline of that country.”
    —Philip Dormer Stanhope, 4th Earl Chesterfield (1694–1773)

    “It is better for a woman to compete impersonally in society, as men do, than to compete for dominance in her own home with her husband, compete with her neighbors for empty status, and so smother her son that he cannot compete at all.”
    —Betty Friedan (b. 1921)

    “He [William Merritt Chase] is, I suspect, getting a very truthful likeness. I would like it better if [it] was not so gray, so cramped about the eyes, and not quite so corpulent. But is this not quarreling with nature?”
    —Rutherford Birchard Hayes (1822–1893)

    “A simple and independent mind does not toil at the bidding of any prince.”
    —Henry David Thoreau (1817–1862)