Coincidental 'near' Ratios of Mean Motion
A number of near-integer-ratio relationships between the orbital frequencies of the planets or major moons are sometimes pointed out (see list below). However, these have no dynamical significance because there is no appropriate precession of perihelion or other libration to make the resonance perfect (see the detailed discussion in the section above). Such near resonances are dynamically insignificant even if the mismatch is quite small because (unlike a true resonance), after each cycle the relative position of the bodies shifts. When averaged over astronomically short timescales, their relative position is random, just like bodies that are nowhere near resonance. For example, consider the orbits of Earth and Venus, which arrive at almost the same configuration after 8 Earth orbits and 13 Venus orbits. The actual ratio is 0.61518624, which is only 0.032% away from exactly 8:13. The mismatch after 8 years is only 1.5° of Venus' orbital movement. Still, this is enough that Venus and Earth find themselves in the opposite relative orientation to the original every 120 such cycles, which is 960 years. Therefore, on timescales of thousands of years or more (still tiny by astronomical standards), their relative position is effectively random.
The presence of a near resonance may reflect that a perfect resonance existed in the past, or that the system is evolving towards one in the future.
Some orbital frequency coincidences include:
(Ratio) and Bodies | Mismatch after one cycle | Randomization time | Probability |
---|---|---|---|
Planets | |||
(9:23) Venus−Mercury | 4.0° | 200 y | 0.19 |
(8:13) Earth−Venus | 1.5° | 1000 y | 0.065 |
(243:395) Earth−Venus | 0.8° | 50,000 y | 0.68 |
(1:3) Mars−Venus | 20.6° | 20 y | 0.11 |
(1:2) Mars−Earth | 42.9° | 8 y | 0.24 |
(1:12) Jupiter−Earth | 49.1° | 40 y | 0.28 |
(2:5) Saturn–Jupiter | 12.8° | 800 y | 0.13 |
(1:7) Uranus−Jupiter | 31.1° | 500 y | 0.18 |
(7:20) Uranus−Saturn | 5.7° | 20,000 y | 0.20 |
(5:28) Neptune−Saturn | 1.9° | 80,000 y | 0.052 |
(1:2) Neptune−Uranus | 14.0° | 2000 y | 0.078 |
Mars system | |||
(1:4) Deimos−Phobos | 14.9° | 0.04 y | 0.083 |
Major asteroids | |||
(1:1) Pallas − Ceres | 1.2° | 700 y | 0.0066 |
(7:18) Jupiter − Pallas | 4.1° | 4000 y | 0.15 |
87 Sylvia system | |||
(17:45) Romulus−Remus | 0.7° | 40 y | 0.067 |
Jupiter system | |||
(1:6) Io−Metis | 0.6° | 2 y | 0.0031 |
(3:5) Amalthea−Adrastea | 3.9° | 0.2 y | 0.064 |
(3:7) Callisto−Ganymede | 0.7° | 30 y | 0.012 |
Saturn system | |||
(2:3) Enceladus−Mimas | 33.2° | 0.04 y | 0.33 |
(2:3) Dione−Tethys | 36.2° | 0.07 y | 0.36 |
(3:5) Rhea−Dione | 17.1° | 0.4 y | 0.26 |
(2:7) Titan−Rhea | 21.0° | 0.7 y | 0.22 |
(1:5) Iapetus−Titan | 9.2° | 4 y | 0.051 |
Major centaurs | |||
(3:4) Uranus−Chariklo | 4.5° | 10,000 y | 0.073 |
Uranus system | |||
(3:5) Rosalind−Cordelia | 0.22° | 4 y | 0.0037 |
(1:3) Umbriel−Miranda | 24.5° | 0.08 y | 0.14 |
(3:5) Umbriel−Ariel | 24.2° | 0.3 y | 0.35 |
(1:2) Titania−Umbriel | 36.3° | 0.1 y | 0.20 |
(2:3) Oberon−Titania | 33.4° | 0.4 y | 0.34 |
Neptune system | |||
(1:20) Triton−Naiad | 13.5° | 0.2 y | 0.075 |
(1:2) Proteus−Larissa | 8.4° | 0.07 y | 0.047 |
Pluto system | |||
(1:3) P5−Charon | 58.5° | 0.2 y | 0.33 |
(1:4) Nix−Charon | 39.1° | 0.3 y | 0.22 |
(1:5) P4−Charon | 9.2° | 2 y | 0.05 |
(1:6) Hydra−Charon | 6.6° | 3 y | 0.037 |
Haumea system | |||
(3:8) Hiʻiaka−Namaka | 42.5° | 2 y | 0.55 |
Read more about this topic: Orbital Resonance
Famous quotes containing the words ratios and/or motion:
“Typography is not only a technology but is in itself a natural resource or staple, like cotton or timber or radio; and, like any staple, it shapes not only private sense ratios but also patterns of communal interdependence.”
—Marshall McLuhan (19111980)
“It is the fixed that horrifies us, the fixed that assails us with the tremendous force of mindlessness. The fixed is a Mason jar, and we cant beat it open. ...The fixed is a world without fire--dead flint, dead tinder, and nowhere a spark. It is motion without direction, force without power, the aimless procession of caterpillars round the rim of a vase, and I hate it because at any moment I myself might step to that charmed and glistening thread.”
—Annie Dillard (b. 1945)