Neats Vs. Scruffies - Relation To Philosophy and Human Intelligence

Relation To Philosophy and Human Intelligence

This conflict goes much deeper than programming practices, (though it clearly has parallels in software engineering). For philosophical or possibly scientific reasons, some people believe that intelligence is fundamentally rational, and can best be represented by logical systems incorporating truth maintenance. Others believe that intelligence is best implemented as a mass of learned or evolved hacks, not necessarily having internal consistency or any unifying organizational framework.

Ironically, the apparently scruffy philosophy may also turn out to be provably (under typical assumptions) optimal for many applications. Intelligence is often seen as a form of search, and as such not believed to be perfectly solvable in a reasonable amount of time (see also NP and Simple Heuristics, commonsense reasoning, memetics, reactive planning).

It is an open question whether human intelligence is inherently scruffy or neat. Some claim that the question itself is unimportant: the famous neat John McCarthy has said publicly he has no interest in how human intelligence works, while famous scruffy Rodney Brooks is openly obsessed with creating humanoid intelligence. (See Subsumption architecture, Cog project (Brooks 2001)).

Read more about this topic:  Neats Vs. Scruffies

Famous quotes containing the words relation to, relation, philosophy, human and/or intelligence:

    “The proper study of mankind is man in his relation to his deity.”
    —D.H. (David Herbert)

    “... a worker was seldom so much annoyed by what he got as by what he got in relation to his fellow workers.”
    —Mary Barnett Gilson (1877–?)

    “If this is philosophy it is at any rate a philosophy that is not in its right mind.”
    —G.C. (Georg Christoph)

    “One might imagine that a movement which is so preoccupied with the fulfillment of human potential would have a measure of respect for those who nourish its source. But politics make strange bedfellows, and liberated women have elected to become part of a long tradition of hostility to mothers.”
    —Elaine Heffner (20th century)

    “No one in this world, so far as I know ... has ever lost money by underestimating the intelligence of the great masses of the plain people.”
    —H.L. (Henry Lewis)