Comparative Perspective
There are two points of view about where Itelmen belongs genetically. According to the first hypothesis, Itelmen and other Chukotko-Kamchatkan languages are derived from one proto-language; the sharp differences of Itelmen, noticed at all levels, are explained by the intense influence of other languages; it is suggested that Itelmen absorbed a different non-Chukotko-Kamchatkan language (V. G. Bogoraz, V. I. Jochelson, P. Y. Skorik). According to the second theory, Itelmen is not related to other Chukotko-Kamchatkan languages; common elements are seen as the effects of convergent evolution (D. Wort, A. P. Volodin, A. S. Asinovsky); thus, there is a basis to consider Itelmen genetically isolated, contrasted with the group of languages Chukotko-Koryak definitely related to Chukotko-Kamchatkan languages. There is also no genetic link between Itelmen and the language of the Ainu (the Southern neighbors of the Itelmen).
Initial comparisons of the Itelmen lexicon to Chukotko-Koryak in terms of the basic lexical stock show that instances of lexical commonality of Itelmen and Chukotko-Koryak languages make up approximately one third, with two thirds of the lexicons sharply distinct. The interpretation of these data are preliminary due to the incompleteness of Chukotko-Kamchatkan comparative phonetics.
Read more about this topic: Itelmen Language
Famous quotes containing the words comparative and/or perspective:
“That hour in the life of a man when first the help of humanity fails him, and he learns that in his obscurity and indigence humanity holds him a dog and no man: that hour is a hard one, but not the hardest. There is still another hour which follows, when he learns that in his infinite comparative minuteness and abjectness, the gods do likewise despise him, and own him not of their clan.”
—Herman Melville (1819–1891)
“The fact that illness is associated with the poor—who are, from the perspective of the privileged, aliens in one’s midst—reinforces the association of illness with the foreign: with an exotic, often primitive place.”
—Susan Sontag (b. 1933)