2000s
| Year | Winner | Nominations |
| 2009 | Metallica for Death Magnetic performed by Metallica | |
| 2008 | Zachary Nipper for Cassadaga performed by Bright Eyes | |
| 2007 | Adam Jones for 10,000 Days performed by Tool | |
| 2006 | Aimee Mann & Gail Marowitz for The Forgotten Arm performed by Aimee Mann | |
| 2005 | Peter Buchanan-Smith & Dan Nadel for A Ghost Is Born performed by Wilco | |
| 2004 | Ani DiFranco & Brian Grunert for Evolve performed by Ani DiFranco | |
| 2003 | Kevin Reagan for Home performed by Dixie Chicks | |
| 2002 | Stanley Donwood & Tchocky for Amnesiac (Special Limited Edition) performed by Radiohead | |
| 2001 | Kevin Reagan for Music performed by Madonna | |
| 2000 | Ray Benson, Sally Carns & Buddy Jackson for Ride With Bob performed by Asleep at the Wheel |
Read more about this topic: Grammy Award For Best Recording Package