- 1968 Chapman 11-0 Delta State
- 1969 Illinois State 12-0 Southwest Missouri State
- 1970 Cal State Northridge 2-1 Nicholls State
- 1971 Florida Southern 4-0 Central Michigan
- 1972 Florida Southern 5-1 Cal State Northridge
- 1973 UC Irvine 9-6 Ithaca
- 1974 UC Irvine 14-1 LSU-New Orleans
- 1975 Florida Southern 10-7 Marietta
- 1976 Cal Poly Pomona 17-3 SIU-Edwardsville
- 1977 UC Riverside 4-1 Eckerd
- 1978 Florida Southern 7-2 Delta State
- 1979 Valdosta State 3-2 Florida Southern
- 1980 Cal Poly Pomona 13-6 New Haven
- 1981 Florida Southern 9-0 Eastern Illinois
- 1982 UC Riverside 10-1 Florida Southern
- 1983 Cal Poly Pomona 9-7 Jacksonville State
- 1984 Cal State Northridge 10-5 Florida Southern
- 1985 Florida Southern 15-5 Cal Poly Pomona
- 1986 Troy State 5-0 Columbus State
- 1987 Troy State 7-5 Tampa
- 1988 Florida Southern 5-4 Sacramento State
- 1989 Cal Poly-SLO 9-5 New Haven
- 1990 Jacksonville State 12-8 Cal State Northridge
- 1991 Jacksonville State 20-4 Missouri Southern
- 1992 Tampa 11-8 Mansfield
- 1993 Tampa 7-5 Cal Poly-SLO
- 1994 Central Missouri State 14-9 Florida Southern
|
- 1995 Florida Southern 15-0 Georgia College
- 1996 Kennesaw State 4-0 St. Joseph's (Ind.)
- 1997 Chico State 13-12 Central Oklahoma
- 1998 Tampa 6-1 Kennesaw State
- 1999 Chico State 11-5 Kennesaw State
- 2000 Southeastern Oklahoma 7-2 Fort Hays State
- 2001 St. Mary's (Tex.) 11-3 Central Missouri State
- 2002 Columbus State 5-3 Chico State
- 2003 Central Missouri State 11-4 Tampa
- 2004 Delta State 12-8 Grand Valley State
- 2005 Florida Southern 12-9 North Florida
- 2006 Tampa 3-2 Chico State
- 2007 Tampa 7-2 Columbus State
- 2008 Mount Olive 6-2 Ouachita Baptist
- 2009 Lynn 2-1 Emporia State
- 2010 Southern Indiana 6-4 UC San Diego
- 2011 West Florida 12-2 Winona State
- 2012 West Chester 9–0 Delta State
|