Premiers
| Season | Premier | Runner Up | Score | Best on Ground |
| 1971 | Torquay | Queenscliff | 18.5 (113) - 6.15 (51) | Graham Muncey Torquay |
| 1972 | Barwon Heads | Ocean Grove | 18.20 (128) - 15.9 (99) | Garry Hamer Barwon Heads |
| 1973 | Barwon Heads | Winchelsea | 19.11 (125) - 11.9 (75) | Brian Marshman Barwon Heads |
| 1974 | Barwon Heads | Ocean Grove | 13.14 (92) - 11.13 (79) | Geoff Fry Barwon Heads |
| 1975 | Queenscliff | Drysdale | 14.16 (100) - 11.10 (76) | Peter Growney Queenscliff |
| 1976 | Drysdale | Torquay | 23.10 (148) - 19.13 (127) | Greg Scott Drysdale |
| 1977 | Drysdale | Queenscliff | 12.10 (82) - 11.12 (78) | David Hall Drysdale |
| 1978 | Portarlington | Drysdale | 12.19 (91) - 5.14 (44) | Vincent Guiffe Portarlington |
| 1979 | Leopold | Newcomb | 18.12 (120) - 17.9 (111) | Peter Lewis Leopold |
| 1980 | Newcomb | Portarlington | 13.17 (95) - 9.12 (66) | Greg Herbet Newcomb |
| 1981 | Newcomb | Portarlington | 19.15 (129) - 10.16 (76) | John Fagan Newcomb |
| 1982 | Newcomb | Torquay | 19.15 (129) - 8.9 (57) | John Fagan Newcomb |
| 1983 | Anglesea | Torquay | 14.14 (98) - 13.6 (84) | Brian O’Keefe Anglesea |
| 1984 | Torquay | Drysdale | 19.11 (125) - 19.10 (124) | Alan Lynch Drysdale |
| 1985 | Drysdale | Leopold | 20.26 (146) - 11.6 (72) | Darren Wilson Drysdale |
| 1986 | Torquay | Newcomb | 21.21 (147) - 4.12 (36) | Shane Jacobsen Torquay |
| 1987 | Torquay | Leopold | 13.16 (94) - 10.14 (74) | Dale Lewis Torquay |
| 1988 | Newcomb | Drysdale | 14.7 (91) - 11.12 (78) | Ross Gibson Newcomb |
| 1989 | Torquay | Drysdale | 11.15 (81) - 9.18 (72) | John McMahon Torquay |
| 1990 | Leopold | Anglesea | 17.5 (107) - 11.13 (79) | Peter Lange Leopold |
| 1991 | Anglesea | Leopold | 10.15 (75) - 5.7 (37) | Darren Fraser Anglesea |
| 1992 | Portarlington | Leopold | 10.6 (66) – 4.11 (35) | Brian Canny Portarlington |
| 1993 | Barwon Heads | Ocean Grove | 19.17 (131) - 10.16 (76) | Antony Callan Barwon Heads |
| 1994 | Ocean Grove | Portarlington | 16.6 (102) - 5.12 (42) | Dean Gills Ocean Grove |
| 1995 | Ocean Grove | Anglesea | 17.12 (114) - 11.11 (77) | Matthew McTaggart Ocean Grove |
| 1996 | Ocean Grove | Anglesea | 12.12 (84) – 7.12 (54) | Steven Sherwell Ocean Grove |
| 1997 | Ocean Grove | Anglesea | 11.10 (76) - 4.2 (26) | Will McTaggart Ocean Grove |
| 1998 | Torquay | Ocean Grove | 9.8 (62) - 6.7 (43) | George Arnold Torquay |
| 1999 | Anglesea | Ocean Grove | 13.16 (94) - 12.12 (84) | Ian Benny Anglesea |
| 2000 | Ocean Grove | Anglesea | 16.13 (109) - 7.12 (54) | Matthew Payne Ocean Grove |
| 2001 | Ocean Grove | Drysdale | 23.16 (154) - 12.8 (80) | Kane Montgomery Ocean Grove |
| 2002 | Ocean Grove | Drysdale | 12.23 (95) - 6.7 (43) | James Dalton Ocean Grove |
| 2003 | Ocean Grove | Geelong Amateur | 12.9 (81) - 10.12 (72) | Liam Rock Ocean Grove |
| 2004 | Geelong Amateur | Ocean Grove | 18.9 (117) - 11.5 (71) | Haami Williams Geelong Amateur |
| 2005 | Newcomb | Torquay | 15.18 (108) - 11.9 (75) | Luke McLean Newcomb |
| 2006 | Torquay | Newcomb | 15.9 (99) - 13.11 (89) | Andrew Wesley Torquay |
| 2007 | Newcomb | Ocean Grove | 25.15 (165) - 17.9 (111) | Mark Stewart Newcomb |
| 2008 | Geelong Amateur | Drysdale | 28.11 (179) - 14.19 (103) | Nathan Reid Geelong Amateur |
| 2009 | Drysdale | Geelong Amateur | 15.18 (108) - 13.12 (90) | Brett Dowie Drysdale |
| 2010 | Drysdale | Geelong Amateur | 13.13 (91) - 11.17 (83) | Mitch Scott Drysdale |
| 2011 | Queenscliff | Geelong Amateur | 17.22 (124) - 13.7 (85) | Daniel Gibbs Queenscliff |
| 2012 | Queenscliff | Torquay | 16.14 (110) - 12.8 (80) | Daniel Gibbs Queenscliff |
Read more about this topic: Bellarine Football League